Indianapolis News and HeadlinesWRTV Investigates


Ex-Indy animal shelter director facing new allegations in Colorado

Doug Rae accused of inhumane treatment of animals
Posted at 12:49 PM, May 30, 2019
and last updated 2019-05-30 22:21:18-04

INDIANAPOLIS — The former director of Indianapolis Animal Care and Control is in hot water once again, this time in Colorado.

Doug Rae is facing new accusations of inhumane treatment of animals, putting the public in danger, and encouraging staff to use expired euthanasia medications.

Rae took over as the director of Indianapolis Animal Care and Control in January 2009 after leaving a chief operating officer job at a Philadelphia shelter.

Rae was a polarizing figure in Indianapolis and was fired eight months later, in October 2009.

During his tenure, the Indianapolis city animal shelter experienced slower response times, an increase in overtime pay, and fewer animals impounded, records show.

Rae also faced criticism for his policies and the way he dealt with animal welfare groups, the public and his own employees

The former director pulled animal control officers off the street to work inside the kennel, a move that some said placed public safety at risk.

Rae is known for his focus on “no kill,” a policy that means a shelter won’t euthanize healthy or treatable animals.

Volunteers and former employees at the Humane Society of Fremont County in Colorado say Rae’s policies have led to unnecessary suffering of animals inside the facility.

RELATED | Insiders describe heartbreaking conditions at Colorado shelter

They spoke with WRTV’s sister station in Denver, KMGH, about the shelter outside of Colorado Springs in Canon City where Doug Rae is executive director.

The accusations included: warehousing dogs that creates unnecessary suffering, using expired euthanizing medications, allowing dogs with bite histories to go to a home with a child and poorly managing dogs that go crazy from prolonged stays in a caged environment.

“We are drowning in dogs that shouldn’t be in kennels, that are suffering, that are going crazy," volunteer Kathy McGregor said. “We are not allowed to tell anybody about it.”

“I worked there for seven months," said Taylor Staton, one of the now-former employees. "I saw the most horrible things. I saw dogs go crazy in their kennels.”

“Dogs are being warehoused,” said Marie Giannelli, another former employee. “Kept sometimes two years and being hurt in the process."

"We are failing these animals,” said Kelly Ramos, who served for 4 ½ years as the shelter’s manager.

“There are dogs that are there so long they are deteriorating,” said McGregor who was recently honored as the shelter’s volunteer of the year. “I wake up at night, and I can’t go back to sleep. These dogs are suffering and there’s nothing we can do about it.”


One of the volunteers and former employees said an example of the problems at the shelter is a dog named Toy Man.

The dog was recently allowed to go home with a couple that had a young child.

Insiders said Toy Man had a bite history and should not have been allowed into a home with a young child.

“That shouldn’t have happened," the former shelter manager Ramos said. "We should have stopped that. It could have been stopped."

Within days of leaving the shelter, Toy Man bit again.

Former employees and the shelter have confirmed he bit the young child in the face, causing more than 40 stitches.


“He goes nuts," Staton said of a dog named Cracker. "He spins and spins in the kennel. He jumps on the chain link fence … he has no nails on the front of his paws, because he rips them out. It’s cruel and inhumane."

Former employees provided KMGH Contact7 Investigates with a video that shows Cracker circling and circling in the kennel and the floor apparently blood-stained from his paws.


“We only had expired euthanizing drugs,” said Staton, who said she was asked to use the expired medications to put down dogs on multiple occasions.

When asked if they were expired by just a few days, she responded, “expired by like three or four years.”

“I would go home at night and just lose it," Ramos said. “I mean, the job is hard enough without having to be made to use expired drugs to euthanize animals and watch them suffer and die.”

Ramos and others said shelter director Doug Rae was responsible for the decision to use the expired medications and not replace them with current meds.


A surprise inspection from investigators with Colorado’s Department of Agriculture (PACFA) confirmed all the accusations raised by the insiders.

The inspection uncovered more than a half dozen violations including:

· Kennels not properly disinfected

· Dogs with bite histories allowed in public areas

· Using expired medications including euthanizing meds

· Mishandling “Cracker”

· Mistakes in the adoption of “Toy Man”

Shelter director: 'This is 100% my fault".

When asked who is responsible for the accusations raised by the insiders and the violations discovered by state inspectors, the former volunteers and employees said they blamed Rae, the Executive Director of the Humane Society of Fremont County.

Many in the group said the heart of the issue is the shelter’s focus on it’s “no kill” philosophy.

They said, at times, that philosophy creates an environment that is inhumane and dangerous for animals.

The shelter’s executive director did agree to sit down and answer all the issues and accusations raised by his former team members.

“'No kill' is important to me,” Rae said, while providing Contact7 with an all-access tour of his shelter. “It simply means you never kill a healthy or treatable animal."

To his credit, the shelter’s executive director did not dodge any question and accepted responsibility for everything discovered in the facility he manages.

He also acknowledged it is an unfortunate situation.

“It is, you know, I didn’t see this coming for the life of me," Rae said.

During a 25-minute on-camera interview, Rae took personal responsibility and accountability for everything addressed by his former employees and volunteers.

“It’s my fault," Rae said. "I said to my board, this is 100% my fault. I should have been all over it and I wasn’t."

When Contact7 Investigates showed Rae the video of Cracker spinning in circles and his kennel apparently blood stained, Rae was told this is what insiders say is part of the “inhumane” picture.

“You’re 100 percent right," Rae said. "It’s not OK that a dog is allowed to do that. It’s just not OK.”

Contact7 Chief Investigative Reporter Tony Kovaleski asked Rae if his intent was to say he was sorry.

“I am very sorry,” Rae said.

At the end of the interview, Rae started tearing up and said, “It just hurts, it just hurts. I should have never let this happen. But it’s not going to happen again. You have my word on that. I think I’ve learned a wicked big lesson here.”

As an example of the change he has promised, Rae showed the Contact7 Investigates team changes in how he is caring for Cracker.

The dog’s paws are no longer bleeding, they have him in a new concrete-free and chain link fence-free kennel, and Rae said what happened before will never happen again.

Rae has been serving as executive director of the Colorado shelter for the last 4.5 years.

RELATED | Animal overpopulation strains Indianapolis resources

As for Indianapolis, the agency is now called Indianapolis Animal Care Services.

The city agency has been through seven directors or interim directors since Doug Rae-- Teri Kendrick, Amber Myers, Dan Shackle, Spencer Moore, Dennis Papenmeier, Randy Dodd and current chief Katie Trennepohl.

Tony Kovaleski, Chief Investigative Reporter for Scripps station KMGH in Denver, contributed to this report.


Contact WRTV Investigates