Indianapolis News and HeadlinesWRTV Investigates


Indianapolis Lyft rider warns of 'vomit fraud' charge

Posted at 3:30 PM, Nov 14, 2019
and last updated 2019-11-15 08:08:18-05

INDIANAPOLIS— If you use a ride sharing service, like Uber or Lyft, beware of unexpected charges on your account.

Call 6 Investigates found some Indiana consumers were charged for clean-up fees for damage they say they didn’t cause — a problem consumers have dubbed “vomit fraud.”

When you use a ride sharing service, you might spill something, get mud on the seat, or get sick, which is why companies have damage or cleaning fees which can range from $20 to $250.

Bea McLaughlin used Lyft to get from her internship to her northside Indianapolis apartment.

It is typically a quick 2-mile ride near Keystone at the Crossing that costs $6 one way.

After one trip, Bea’s bank notified her about a charge on her account.

“I got a notification two days later that I had been charged $100 for Lyft damages,” Bea said.

The Lyft driver accused Bea of leaving a blood stain in the backseat, but Bea is adamant it wasn’t her.

"It's completely ridiculous," Bea said. “I noticed it when I got in, and it didn’t really look like blood. It looked like someone had spilled coffee or juice.”

When Bea reached out to Lyft customer service, they sided with the driver and refused to give Bea her money back.

“We review each case extensively and the validity of the claim is based on the photos and information provided by the driver at the time they reported the case,” read an emailed response to Bea from Lyft customer service. “Your driver identified the damage in question as blood.”

Bea was also informed, “if a ride matches the anecdotal evidence of the situation given by a driver then a fee will be charged accordingly.”

Bea’s father Jim McLaughlin contacted Call 6 Investigates.

“I’m reaching out because I’m an enraged father,” Jim said.

Jim said while many people may not notice a $100 charge, he says his daughter is a broke college student.

“You're guilty until proven innocent,” Jim said. “How do you disprove a negative? That's basically what this whole thing is about."

Bea is not alone.

Call 6 Investigates found hundreds of ride sharing consumers across the country have filed complaints to several organizations including the Better Business Bureau.

Complaints include passengers claiming Lyft and Uber drivers wrongly charged them damage fees for things like scratches, food and drink stains, and even dog feces.

Mark Castle, a Pinellas County Florida rider, said he was charged $100 fee for vomiting in a Lyft.

"t definitely made me feel very taken advantage of," Castle said. “When Lyft just kind of shrugged it off it just made me feel very gaslit like I’m just lying or being dramatic.”

The BBB says “vomit fraud” complaints are on the rise, as more and more passengers use ride sharing as a way to get around.

“Who knows who did the damage or when it occurred,” Tim Maniscalo, CEO of the BBB Serving Central Indiana, said. “I think it's important they get the right person who caused the damage and not accuse just anyone on maybe some flimsy evidence. I think they should do a very thorough investigation and before you accuse somebody, have the evidence and investigation done."

Lyft policy says you can be charged up to $250 for damage or cleaning.

“Lyft reserves the right (but is not obligated) to verify or otherwise require documentation of damages prior to processing the Damage Fee,” read the Lyft website.

Uber’s website says small messes can cost you $20, vomit $40, larger food or beverage spills $80, and $150 for a significant amount of bodily fluids.

Call 6 Investigates reached out to Lyft about Bea’s $100 blood stain charge, and later that day, Bea got an email refunding about half of the damage fee.

The company said Bea’s claim was handled in accordance with Lyft policy.

“We take damage disputes such as these very seriously. Lyft’s support team investigates each incident individually and makes a determination based on the evidence available," read the statement.

Lyft reviews evidence including statements from all involved parties, photographs and prior feedback.

Bea and Jim McLaughlin say ride sharing companies need to better investigate claims before charging customers, even if it means putting cameras in vehicles.

“I know it would be a hassle, but it would keep people from being charged for something they didn’t do,” Bea said.

Uber updated its receipt requirement policy in May to help prevent vomit fraud.

As part of the policy, Uber’s team takes additional steps to confirm with the cleaning fee charges with the cleaning vendor, according to Kayla Whaling, Uber Media Relations.

“Participating in fraudulent activity of any kind is a clear violation of our Community Guidelines. We are constantly evaluating our processes and technology related to these claims and will take appropriate action whenever fraud may be detected,” read the Uber statement.

How to protect yourself:

  • Look at the ratings for drivers
  • Make sure you understand company policies before you ride
  • Take a picture of your seat before and after your ride
  • Report any damage you see to your driver
  • If you did damage the vehicle, pay the fee
  • If you didn’t, file a dispute with Uber or Lyft and your credit card company