News and HeadlinesWRTV Investigates


Seven teacher licenses suspended amid state’s largest ISTEP cheating case

Posted at 4:33 PM, Jan 15, 2019

GARY — Seven teacher licenses are now suspended following what the Indiana Department of Education is calling the largest ISTEP cheating case the state has ever seen.

The state’s investigation began when the test’s vendor Pearson alerted the Indiana Department of Education about irregularities at Frankie W. McCullough Academy for Girls in Gary following the 2017 ISTEP.

ISTEP, or Indiana Statewide Testing for Educational Progress, is administered to students in grades 3 through 8 to measure skills like reading, writing and math.

The investigation found McCullough staff failed to follow prescribed testing protocols and did not maintain a secure testing environment.

“Eight sections of the ISTEP+ in grades 3-6 had abnormally high changes of answers from wrong to right,” state records showed. “Staff at McCullough had no explanation for how this could have occurred and did not report anything unusual during ISTEP+ administration.”

IDOE spokesperson Adam Baker said the agency’s investigation showed students changed their answers from wrong to right up to 13 times, when the typical number is one time.

"One of the most interesting things is we had a 3rd grader who took ISTEP and their portion for the average third grader was 4-6 hours but she took it in 18 minutes,” Baker said. “When we are looking at things like that that are almost screaming to get caught. It's just blatant."

IDOE also found some McCullough students opened sessions of their exam on one day, and finished it another, which is not allowed.

Baker said IDOE takes ISTEP cheating very seriously.

“You’re left with students who don’t have a true depiction of themselves,” Baker said. “They don’t know how well they’re doing. We don’t know how well their doing.”

IDOE invalidated the school’s 2017 ISTEP results, and worked with the school to send a letter to parents explaining what happened.

Baker acknowledged some teachers and administrators in Indiana feel pressure to perform well on the ISTEP.

Baker said the educators involved in the McCullough case have not provided a motive or explanation to how the irregularities happened.

“It’s important that we work with educators to ensure the validity of these tests,” he said.

Baker said there was a one in a billion chance that McCullough’s test results could have occurred naturally without answer manipulation by someone.

Call 6 Investigates reached out to Gary Community School Corporation’s emergency manager Pete Morikis via phone and email Monday but we have not yet heard back.

The state recently took over Gary Community schools amid massive debt and academic failures.

Following its investigation into ISTEP irregularities, the Indiana Department of Education filed a total of nine complaints against educators.

Two people voluntarily agreed to have their teaching licenses suspended, records show:

  • Pearl Prince, principal, license suspended for three years
  • Amelia Villanueva, teacher, license suspended for two years

IDOE had a two-day hearing on Nov. 29 and 30.

An administrative law judge issued findings against five educators:

  • Denine Scott, teacher, license suspended for two years
  • Gina Hannah, teacher, license suspended for two years
  • Nina Peterson, teacher, license suspended for two years
  • Rita Jackson, teacher, license suspended for two years
  • Bridget McFadden, teacher, license suspended for two years

Call 6 Investigates also contacted the suspended educators via email, but none of them responded with a comment.

The judge found there was not enough evidence in the two remaining educators to warrant a license suspension.

Records show the district blamed technological difficulties for the irregularities.

A recent Call 6 Investigation found since 2012, the Indiana Department of Education has revoked or suspended the licenses of 108 educators including teachers, counselors and administrators.

PREVIOUS | Teachers who lose their licenses can still work with kids

ISTEP impropriety was the second most common reason for a teacher losing their license.

The top reason — child seduction.

Sexual misconduct with a minor, battery, child pornography and child exploitations were among the other reasons for educators losing their licenses to work with children.

Under state law, the Indiana Department of Education automatically and permanently revokes licenses after certain offenses, such as child molesting, child solicitation, child exploitation, sexual misconduct with a minor and rape.

MORE TOP STORIES| Noblesville police respond to unsafe sledding call | Lafayette police release body cam footage from incident where officer shot by fellow officer | Man who led police on chase that ended on interstate took his own life | Indiana issuing February food stamps early | IMPD search for man who threw bag from car with injured puppy inside

Top Trending Videos