NewsWRTV Investigates


State issues warning about Craigslist car sales involving dealers

Call 6 exposed private sellers didn’t disclose problems
Posted at 4:40 PM, Jul 01, 2019
and last updated 2019-07-01 16:40:24-04

INDIANAPOLIS — If you shop for cars online, you need to use caution when browsing on Craigslist.

The Indiana Attorney General’s office issued a warning Monday about car dealers posing as private sellers on Craigslist.

Dealers are prohibited by Craigslist from advertising under “by owner,” and dealers who post misleading ads by posing as private sellers could be in violation of Indiana’s Deceptive Consumer Sales Act, according to the Indiana Attorney General’s office.

The warning comes after Call 6 Investigates exposed private Craigslist sellers often failed to disclose a car’s hidden problems to potential buyers, including open recalls, prior crashes, as well as branded titles such as “rebuilt” and “not actual mileage.”

PREVIOUS | Car sellers on Craigslist fail to disclose hidden problems

According to the state, misleading dealers will:

  • post photos of vehicles parked in residential neighborhood settings rather than on dealer lots
  • write ads appearing to be from private sellers, using language such as “I am selling my…”
  • provide contact information simply featuring someone’s first name and cell number, omitting any mention of the dealership or the dealership’s phone number or address.

The Attorney General’s office found dealership employees often direct potential buyers to their commercial lots — hoping that once they have a customer interested in a specific vehicle, the consumer will agree to buy the vehicle from the dealer regardless of the consumer’s original intentions.

The Office of the Attorney General is currently investigating multiple dealers who misled consumers using Craigslist.

“These dealers are typically trying to reach an audience of car buyers who want to avoid interactions with dealers,” the Attorney General’s office said. “Such consumers typically do not wish to pay dealer fees or subject themselves to aggressive sales tactics.”

Unlike licensed car dealerships, Craigslist and other sites are typically unregulated.

On Craigslist, it’s easy to find vehicle ads that sound great with phrases like “clean title,” “amazing shape,” and “no problems at all.”

Call 6 Investigates used the plate numbers to run vehicle history reports on sites like Carfax and Autocheck and uncovered problems like open safety recalls, prior crashes, and branded titles.

RELATED| Resources to run a VIN check | Uncovering cars crash history often up to consumers

If you feel you’ve been victimized by deceptive ads on Craigslist or elsewhere you can file a consumer complaint with the Office of the Attorney General at or by calling 1-800-382-5516.

Stream WRTV anytime!

Contact WRTV Investigates