News and HeadlinesIndianapolis Local NewsCrime


Police allege footprints, DNA tie suspect to trail murder

Posted at 2:07 PM, May 09, 2019

ZIONSVILLE — A 23-year-old Zionsville man was arrested in connection with the shooting death of a man near a popular walking trail after police discovered footprints in the mud, a discarded .357 revolver and DNA evidence linking him to the crime.

In court documents filed Wednesday in Boone Circuit Court, police allege the evidence connects James Earl Hughes, 23, to the April 28 shooting death of Samuel T. Bennett, 23. Hughes has been arrested and charged with murder.

Bennett's body was found in a retention pond near the Big-4 Rail Trail in Zionsville. An autopsy determined he had been shot twice.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE | Zionsville police have no suspects in man's death near trail| Police focused on solving Zionsville shooting death | Zionsville man arrested on firearms charge | Zionsville police arrest man in shooting death on Rail Trail

Bennett's family issued a statement on Thursday through Jennifer Hallowell, of Hallowell Consulting:

Our family is grateful to the various law enforcement agencies and officers for their thorough and swift action leading to the arrest. We appreciate the outpouring of support from the community and ask only to be provided with privacy and your continued prayers as we deal with the unimaginable loss of our beloved Sam.

In a probable cause affidavit, a Zionsville police detective said officers searching the area found a very distinct footprint in the mud of a creek bed near the trail. The footprints were distinctive and contained multiple small hexagonal shapes in it.

As the officer continued to search, he found additional footprints and called for another officer who arrived and found additional footprints and a black revolver.

The detective wrote in the affidavit the revolver was found 100 to 150 yards from where Bennett's body was found.

According to court documents, all five of the cartridges in the cylinder of the revolver had primer strikes, however one of the cartridges failed to fire. Police said that was consistent with multiple 911 calls reporting the gunshots that said there were multiple shots fired, then a pause, and then another gunshot.

During the recovery, the revolver was swabbed for DNA evidence in five separate areas — trigger, front sight, hammer, grip and side.

The gun was tracked to a David Meschino who told police he purchased the gun in 2018 for Hughes who was allegedly unable to buy firearms due to having a felony conviction. According to court records, Meschino allegedly told investigators that someone "had a beef with James" and Hughes was worried.

Meschino is charged with criminal transfer of a firearm.

According to court documents, Hughes was taken by his parents to St. Vincent Stress Center in Indianapolis on the evening of the shooting on the advice of an attorney.

Police obtained a search warrant for a DNA sample from Hughes which was collected and sent to the Indiana State Police Indianapolis Forensic Laboratory for comparison to DNA samples taken from the gun. According to court records, the DNA on the gun matched Hughes' DNA.

Investigators also found New Balance tennis shoes identified as belonging to Hughes at the St. Vincent facility that had an apparent mud stains. The soles also had a pattern containing multiple hexagonal shapes, police said.