One Indiana Republican state senator lost Tuesday to a challenger backed by President Donald Trump, while another incumbent survived in two of seven races that are testing the president's influence in a deep red state.
Blake Fletcher, who had Trump's backing, defeated state Sen. Travis Holdman, while Sen. Greg Goode held off a challenge from Trump-backed Brenda Wilson.
Trump targeted seven Indiana state senators who defied months of White House pressure by voting against mid-decade redistricting. Trump undertook the national campaign to redraw congressional maps to boost his party’s chances in the November midterm elections.
Twenty-one Republican senators voted against redistricting in December, including eight running for reelection this year. Trump has endorsed primary challengers against seven, and the president's allies have spent millions of dollars on races that rarely get much attention from Washington.
It's become a costly and unprecedented intraparty battle that has exacerbated tensions among Republicans ahead of the November midterm elections that will determine control of Congress.
Holdman, a lawyer from the Fort Wayne area, was elected to the Indiana Senate in 2008. He was chairman of the Senate Republican caucus and was considered by his colleagues to be even-tempered. After Trump had publicly railed against Senate Leader Rodric Bray, Holdman replied, “That kind of language doesn’t help.”
Prior to the returns Tuesday, Holdman said, “I’m at peace with however it goes.”
Indiana Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith said the primary is about how far the party will go to get an edge over Democrats — a contest between “the Republicans who tend to want to avoid the fight and the Republicans who feel like we need to fight."
“So the only question is, ‘Will you fight or will you get trampled by the other side?’” said Beckwith, who is supporting the Trump-backed challengers.
Indiana rejected Trump on redistricting
Trump began leaning on Republican-led states last year to redraw their congressional maps to make it easier for his party to hold its thin majority in the U.S. House. Although redistricting is normally done once a decade, after a new census, Trump wanted to abandon tradition to gain a political edge.
Texas was the first to follow through, and the White House pressured Indiana to go along too. Vice President JD Vance met with state politicians in Washington and Indianapolis, and Trump weighed in by conference call.
However, Indiana senators rebuffed the effort, one of the president's first significant political defeats of his second term.
The redistricting fight divided Republicans in Indiana, a state Trump won three times by no less than 16 points. Republican Gov. Mike Braun, U.S. Sen. Jim Banks and organizations such as Turning Point Action have worked alongside Trump to unseat the incumbents.
Jim Bopp, a prominent Indiana attorney who leads a political action committee aligned with Braun, predicted that Trump’s support will carry the day for the challengers.
“Republican voters overwhelmingly support Trump, and when they find out Trump has endorsed a particular Senate candidate, they swing their support behind them,” he said.
In Columbus, redistricting opponent Sen. Greg Walker's district, Ronda Millig voted for his challenger Michelle Davis, but not because Trump supported her.
Instead, she said she was influenced by the onslaught of advertising against Walker. Super PACs connected with Banks and Braun combined to spend more than $1.3 million in advertising attacking him.
Combined the two groups spent more than $8.3 million on the seven Senate races, according to the ad-tracking firm AdImpact.
“I really believed some of the things I had heard about him,” said Millig, a retiree who lives in the Columbus area. “It didn’t seem like he was someone I wanted in office.”
But Milling did not say that Trump’s endorsement was the deciding factor.
“That doesn’t always mean anything,” she said.
Emily Bohall Board, voting in Columbus, said she had never voted in a Republican primary before Tuesday. But the redistricting influenced her to vote for Walker.
“Greg Walker is the only option not supported by Donald Trump, and I have been very upset about everything Trump has done,” said Board, who is 37 and an occupational therapist.
Madison Long, who is 28 and a lawyer, who also voted for Walker, criticized Davis for her ties to Trump.
“She doesn’t have any promises of her own or any agenda of her own. Her goal is to just follow Trump,” Long said. “I find that extremely concerning given the nature of the nationwide politics.”
Indiana opposition came from constituents, former governor
Opposition to the effort came from anti-Trump Republicans and those wary of the president reaching so deeply into state decision-making. Former Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels, who had stepped away from politics after leaving the governorship in 2015, reemerged to help raise money for targeted incumbents.
The senators who broke with Trump said they were listening to constituents who were overwhelmingly against his redistricting plan. Some said they didn’t like Trump's aggressive tone in pushing the plan.
“We hate to be told what to do,” said Mike Murphy, a former Republican state representative. “We’re very independent-thinking people. So when Donald Trump and his goons come in and try to tell us that we need to redistrict to help his political future, that’s the worst thing you can do.”
He said Trump and those spending big money to take out the incumbents don’t understand Indiana politics.
“There’s just so many misjudgments on people’s part because they tend to fly at the 50,000-foot level, and they don’t go to the barbecues and the church fish fries and the things that make Indiana politics,” Murphy said.
Bopp, who supports the Trump-backed challengers, said the primary is a chance for Indiana Republicans to express how important it is to redraw the congressional lines there.
“It’s not a matter of Trump’s power,” Bopp said. “It’s about Republican primary voters who support his agenda and don’t want a Democratic House that will be hugely destructive to the Trump presidency and the country.”
This story will be updated throughout the night. Check back for updates.
