NewsWRTV Investigates


Judge grants preliminary injunction against Greenfield Granite at request of Attorney General

Company accused of not finishing headstones
Greenfield Granite
Posted at 11:51 AM, Sep 29, 2020
and last updated 2020-09-29 13:24:47-04

HANCOCK COUNTY — A Hancock County judge granted the Indiana Attorney General’s office motion Tuesday for a preliminary injunction against Greenfield Granite, a monument business that’s faced accusations they took money from consumers and didn’t complete the work.

This will allow the Indiana Attorney General’s office two weeks to take an inventory of the business located at 952 W. Main Street.

The state filed a lawsuit on September 18, accusing Greenfield Granite of violating the Indiana Deceptive Consumer Sales Act and the Senior Consumer Protection Act.

The injunction prevents Greenfield Granite from liquidating, selling, transferring, or dispensing monuments, headstones and other products.

The company also can’t engage in customer sales if it cannot fulfill the order within the time period stated to the consumer.

In its request for a preliminary injunction, the Attorney General’s office included the case of Mary Collins, who told WRTV Investigates in August she paid $1,850 for her husband’s headstone but never received it or a refund.

PREVIOUS | Grieving families upset with headstone company over delays

The Attorney General’s office told the court they were concerned about the headstones and cremated remains still on the property.

“Individuals have been observed at the business property during the week of September 15, 2020,” read the complaint. “These individuals have turned away consumers searching for their monuments, but appear to be working. An injunction during the pendency of this action will prevent waste of business assets that can be used to make consumers whole.”

The Attorney General’s office is asking a court for nearly $20,000 in restitution for customers who paid for headstones but never got their stones or a refund.

The Greenfield Police Department has received more than 70 complaints that Greenfield Granite failed to fulfill orders properly.

In its lawsuit, the Attorney General’s office outlined complaints from at least 18 customers, including several who had been interviewed by WRTV Investigates in August — Mary Collins, Melissa Rieskamp, and Sheila Carson — and who were awaiting headstones or refunds from the company.

PREVIOUS | Grieving families upset with headstone company over delays

Some of the customers received headstones, but they were not done correctly, records show.

“We have laws in place to protect Hoosiers when businesses abandon their obligations to customers,” Attorney General Hill said. “In this case, we want to ensure that any consumers harmed by this company’s business practices receive refunds or, if they prefer, have their orders fulfilled if products remain available.”

Hill added Greenfield Granite’s area of specialty makes this case especially troubling.

“No one with an ounce of compassion wants to hear about a business taking advantage of grieving customers trying to achieve closure after losing loved ones,” he said.

The judge also granted a temporary restraining order against Greenfield Granite.

“The temporary restraining order, or TRO, is important because it prevents the company from dissipating any assets and allows the State to assess the current status of the company,” said Scott Barnhart, director of Consumer Protection at the Indiana Attorney General’s office. “This will help determine how to reconcile this for distressed customers who never received the gravestones they ordered as they were dealing with the heartbreak of the deaths of their loved ones.”

WRTV Investigates is working to get a response from Greenfield Granite.

No attorney is listed for the company in court records.

On September 8, Greenfield Granite owner Amie Strohl, died by suicide hours before she was scheduled to appear in court to face allegations in a civil lawsuit against her.

Consumers say Strohl’s husband appeared in court on the company’s behalf on Tuesday morning.

At the time of Amie Strohl’s death, Greenfield Police had been conducting a criminal investigation into Greenfield Granite after receiving numerous complaints from consumers about paying for headstones and not receiving the product or a refund.

Tips for the Indiana Attorney General’s Office on dealing with a business:

· Document everything

· Keep copies of contract, receipts

· Retain emails, text messages and other communications

· Keep track of first and last names of employees you work with

· File a complaint at

· Prior to hiring, search for criminal or civil actions at

· Ask for references

· Never pay all the money upfront

· Hold back at least half of the money upon completion

Stream WRTV anytime!

Contact WRTV Investigates