News and HeadlinesIndianapolis Local NewsCrime


Armed robbery suspect mistakenly released from jail in Indy, re-arrested on warrant hours later

Posted at 1:19 PM, Apr 14, 2022

INDIANAPOLIS — A man accused in a string of armed robberies is back in custody after being mistakenly freed from the jail in Marion County on Wednesday.

Records show Lance McGee, 29, was not in custody Wednesday, the same day he was scheduled to appear for an initial hearing on nine felony charges stemming from his role in a series of armed robberies.

Marion Superior Court Magistrate Anne Flannelly issued a warrant for McGee's arrest, court records show. Capt. Mitch Gore, a spokesman for the Marion County Sheriff's Office, said McGee was arrested again on Wednesday night, just hours later.

"The (Marion County Sheriff's Office) received an automatic electronic notification that the (Marion County Prosecutor's Office) was declining to prosecute Mr. McGee," Gore told WRTV. "He was accordingly released as is standard procedure."

Michael Leffler, a spokesman for Prosecutor Ryan Mears, told WRTV that McGee was released because of a "computer error."

"A computer error falsely notified sheriff’s office staff that charges would not be filed," Leffler said. "We are continuing to investigate the circumstances of this incident."

Judge Cynthia L. Oetjen ordered McGee to be held without bond until April 20, when bond would be set at $200,000, records show.

McGee and Donta Allen, 24, were arrested April 8 after prosecutors say they tried to rob a south-side Game Stop, 6905 S. Emerson Avenue. Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department SWAT officers found both men, along with evidence connected to the robbery, in a vehicle near the scene.

It's still unclear how long after his initial arrest on April 8 McGee was released and why.

Mcgee and Allen are both charged in the following 2022 robberies:

  • Disc Replay at 8210 Rockville Road on March 25
  • Game Stop at 3269 W. 86th Street on March 27
  • Auto Zone at 4606 E. County Line Road on March 27
  • Game Stop at 4525 Lafayette Road on April 2
  • Auto Zone at 7455 Michigan Road on April 2
  • Disc Replay at 7317 US 31 South on April 5
  • Auto Zone at 8525 Southeastern Avenue on April 5
  • Auto Zone at 6055 E. 82nd Street on April 5
  • Game Stop at 6905 S. Emerson Avenue on April 8

Allen is also charged in the robbery of the Disc Replay at 9739 E. Washington Street on April 3. He faces a total of 10 counts of armed robbery, 10 counts of criminal confinement, unlawful possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon and escape.

Rick Snyder, president of the Indianapolis chapter of the Fraternal Order of Police, has been a vocal critic of what he calls the county's"revolving door" criminal justice system.

"Here again is another example where we have more questions than answers, and we have violent offenders who have been recycled back in our neighborhoods," Snyder said.

Rick Snyder.jpg
Indianapolis FOP President Rick Snyder

Contact WRTV reporter Vic Ryckaert at or on Twitter: @vicryc.