SHELBYVILLE — A Shelbyville man will spend more than 43 years in prison after pleading guilty to two courts of murder for hire, witness tampering, illegally possessing a firearm and producing and distributing child sexual abuse material.
This story begins with Robert Mason Elliott, 28, meeting a 16-year-old girl in 2017.
Eventually, Elliott was charged with domestic battery involving the teen and later dealing narcotics and producing and distributing child sex abuse material of he girl, according to court documents.
While in jail on those charges, in February 2018, Elliott called his mother and told her to hire a hitman – specifically from the motorcycle club Hells Angels—to kill or injure the girl to stop her from testifying against him.
As his mother attempted to hire a member of Hells Angels, authorities stopped the plan, according to court documents.
After this, Elliott attempted to hire inmates within the Shelby County Jail by offering $5,000 to kill the girl and her mother, according to court documents. Multiple inmates told police of these discussions.
In May 2019, Elliott reached out to a “hitman” from the “cartel” and offered military-grade weapons, a motorcycle and more if he fulfilled the hit on the girl and her mother, according to court documents.
Little to Elliott’s knowledge – the “hitman” was an undercover federal agent.
In June, Elliott pleaded guilty and this week he was sentenced to 520 months in prison.
“The defendant’s heinous, violent crimes demonstrate an utter disrespect for the law or the value of human life,” said Zachary A. Myers, United States Attorney for the Southern District of Indiana.
-
Missing juvenile prompts multi-agency search of Lake Michigan in Laporte County
A multi-agency search is underway after a juvenile went missing in Lake Michigan near the Michigan City Lighthouse Pier Monday afternoon.
Stray gunfire strikes Elkhart home, critically injures toddler
A toddler is now in critical condition in the hospital after she was struck by a stray bullet while sleeping in her Elkhart home.
Ballard secures signatures needed for November ballot amid fraud controversy
Independent Secretary of State candidate and former Indianapolis mayor Greg Ballard announced his campaign has submitted the petition signatures needed to secure a spot on the November ballot.
Speedway Police searching for missing 15-year-old girl last seen June 16
Jaylena Smith, a 15-year-old Black female, was last seen on the west side of Indianapolis in Speedway on June 16, 2026, between 8:30 a.m. and 10:30 a.m.
