INDIANAPOLIS — A 19-year-old man has been arrested and faces preliminary charges of robbery and murder stemming from the May 2022 shooting death of a man at a CITGO gas station.
According to police, the teen was arrested this week after an investigation into the shooting at the gas station in the 1800 block of N. Rural Street that killed 46-year-old Gary Underwood.
Underwood was initially taken to the hospital in critical condition but died at the hospital.
Court documents allege Underwood was getting into his 2008 Hummer H3 when another man, now identified by police as 19-year-old Ronald Newman, entered the Hummer and fired shots at Underwood.
The gas station clerk ran outside and noticed Underwood on the ground and the other man driving away in the Hummer, according to court documents.
According to court documents, this is seen in surveillance at the gas station.
In the aftermath, police released photos of the suspect to the public.
A second armed carjacking that occurred the same day at a Marathon gas station in the 400 block of N. Sherman Drive was linked to the shooting.
The vehicle from this carjacking was located and a DNA swab led police to identify Ronald Newman.
Matching identities from the two carjacking incidents connected Newman to the shooting of Underwood, according to court documents.
Furthermore, Newman’s GPS monitoring device from a prior conviction stopped during the 26 minutes that passed during the carjacking at CITGO.
Newman was taken into custody on February 14.
Anyone with further information about the incident is asked to contact Detective Ryan Clark at the IMPD Homicide Office at 317-327-3475 or email him at Ryan.Clark@indy.gov.
Tips can also be made anonymously to Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana at 317-262-8477.
-
Noblesville nonprofit building affordable housing for vulnerable adults
A Noblesville nonprofit is transforming six unsafe properties into affordable housing, specifically designed for people facing serious mental health challenges.
FBI disrupts 'ISIS-inspired' plot by juvenile at Indiana high school
The FBI disrupted an ISIS-inspired plot targeting a central Indiana high school, according to the agency's 2025 annual report highlighting significant increases in arrests and public safety impacts.
Congressman Jim Baird and his wife recovering after car accident
U.S. Representative Jim Baird is hospitalized after a car accident and expected to make a full recovery, according to a statement from his office.
Fire cadet programs ignite career paths for Indiana teens
Fire cadet programs across central Indiana are helping students discover meaningful careers in public service by providing early training, mentorship and life-saving skills.
